FMC Commissioner Creel Announces Departure � Dye, Brennan Lone Commissioners
Federal Maritime Commissioner
Harold J. Creel, Jr. announced that he will leave the agency when his term ends on June 30, 2009.
Commissioner Creel is ending a nearly 15-year career with the Commission. Commissioner Creel joined the FMC in
1994 after he was nominated by President Bill Clinton. He became Chairman of the Commission in February 1996
and served in that capacity until August 2002. His seven-year tenure as Chairman is the longest in the
agency’s history. As Chairman he oversaw the revision of Commission regulations to implement the Ocean
Shipping Reform Act (OSRA) of 1998. He also guided major investigations into shipping practices of Japan and
China. In 1997, he took bold action against Japan by banning Japanese ships from U.S. ports in retaliation for
unfair practices at Japanese ports.
The FMC’s 2003 investigation of alleged Shipping Act violations by the Transpacific Stabilization Agreement (TSA) was another major action in which Commissioner
Creel took part. As a result of this investigation, the Commission ordered the TSA Carriers to pay a
record-breaking penalty of $1,350,000 – this was later reduced, but the group did remove the Indian
Sub-Continent from the scope of its FMC agreements, and some observers thought the investigation helped level the
playing field between carriers and NVOCCs. In 2004, Commissioner Creel worked to give NVOCCs service contract
authority in the form of Non-Vessel-Operating Common Carrier Agreements (NSAs).
“I have thoroughly enjoyed my time at the Federal Maritime Commission and working with my esteemed colleagues
and staff,” Commissioner Creel said. “I know that I leave the agency in good hands to carry out the
important mission of the Federal Maritime Commission.” Creel will be joining the government relations
firm of Alcalde & Fay in Arlington, VA. After
his departure, the five-seat Commission will be left with only two sitting Commissioners: Commissioner
Joseph Brennan, a former Governor of Maine, originally appointed by President Bill Clinton in 1999, and Commissioner
Rebecca Dye of North Carolina, appointed by President George W. Bush in 2002. President Barack Obama has yet to nominate anyone to fill
the remaining seats. The FMC has been without a Chairman for almost three years now. The last FMC
Chairman, Steven Blust, left the agency in November 2006.
Clean Truck Rulings: ATA Injunction Granted in L.A., but FMC Loses in D.C.
A California U.S. District Court has temporarily halted
some key provisions of the Clean Truck Programs at the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach.
Foremost among the provisions struck down by the court is the Port of Los Angeles’ employee-only mandate that
would have eventually banned independent owner-operator truckers from the port. This ruling is a victory for
the American Trucking Associations, which
took issue with the numerous trucker requirements outlined in the ports’ Clean Truck Programs. The ATA
argued that the Clean Truck Programs effectively re-regulate the trucking industry by requiring truckers to sign
restrictive concession agreements that mandate everything from off-street parking to health insurance for
On April 27, Justice Christina Snyder issued a preliminary ruling enjoining the ports from requiring trucking
companies to use employee drivers exclusively, to provide drivers with health insurance and to pay annual port fees
for registering trucks. The court did not enjoin aspects of the concession agreements that it deemed
safety-related, and it did not take any action to stop the ports from collecting the Clean Truck Fees of $35 per 20ft container
and $70 per 40ft container that were implemented earlier this year. Justice Snyder originally refused to grant
the ATA’s request for a preliminary injunction, stating in her December 2008 opinion that the Clean Truck
Programs’ public health benefits outweighed economic hardships to truckers. However, she was forced to
reverse her decision after the United States Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit ordered her to issue a preliminary injunction against “unconstitutional
provisions” of the Clean Truck Programs. A final ruling in the ATA case is expected by December
While the ATA was victorious in L.A., the Federal Maritime Commission was not successful in D.C. The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia denied
the FMC’s request for a permanent injunction barring portions of the Clean Truck Programs. Judge Richard A. Leon declined to grant the
FMC’s request, saying the Commission failed to demonstrate that the programs would result in a significant
loss of competition. The FMC had sought a permanent injunction of not only the programs’ trucking
concession agreements and employee-only mandate, but also many aspects of the Clean Truck Fees. The FMC
has not appealed the Court’s decision and has indicated it is considering its options.
TSA Carriers Increase Bunker Adjustment Factors for Monthly BAF
The carrier members of the Transpacific Stabilization Agreement (TSA), FMC Agreement No. 011223,
serving the East Asia/USA trade lane announced increases to Bunker Adjustment Factors (BAF) calculated using its old
monthly BAF formula. Last month, the TSA announced a switch from monthly to quarterly BAF and a new
calculation formula. However, cargo moving under tariff rates and 2008-09 service contracts that extend beyond
May 1, 2009 are still subject to BAF calculated using TSA’s old monthly calculation formula.
June 2009 BAF calculated using TSA’s old monthly formula will increase to US$ 364 per 20ft container, US$ 455
per 40ft container, US$ 512 per 40ft hi-cube container, US$ 596 per 45ft container, and US$ 10 per WM (LCL).
Quarterly BAF according to TSA’s new formula is as follows for the period of April 1 – June 30, 2009:
shipments via West Coast Service – US$ 118 per 20ft container, US$ 148 per 40ft container, US$ 167 per 40ft hi-cube
container, US$ 187 per 45ft container; shipments via East Coast Service – US$ 247 per 20ft container, US$ 309
per 40ft container, US$ 348 per 40ft hi-cube container, US$ 391 per 45ft container. The TSA’s 14 carrier
members are American President Lines, CSCL, CMA-CGM, COSCO Container Lines, Evergreen Marine, Hanjin
Shipping, Hapag-Lloyd Container Line, Hyundai Merchant Marine, “K” Line, Mediterranean Shipping, NYK
Line, OOCL, Yang Ming Marine and Zim Integrated Shipping Services. The group’s web
site at www.tsacarriers.org provides additional
TSA Carriers Desperate to Increase Rates, Beat Back �Panic Mentality�
The carrier members of the Transpacific Stabilization Agreement (TSA) announced new efforts to
establish a floor on rates and stabilize freight revenues. The group agreed to establish minimum rates of
$1350 for West Coast and $2500 for East Coast all-water service for 40 ft containers, with rates for high cube
containers $100 higher than standard 40 ft rates. Minimums for selected mini-land bridge and inland point
destinations are also planned. The group also plans to expire all “spot rates” within 30 days and
will make all 2009-2010 service contracts subject to full, floating bunker charges as per its new quarterly
formula. Additionally, the TSA Carriers have agreed all 2009-2010 contracts will expire no later than April
30, 2010 – presumably to make it easier to impose rate increases effective May 1, 2010.
In March the TSA Carriers announced a two-step plan to stabilize rates. That plan consisted of expiring
reduced short term/spot rates by the end of June and increasing rates for 40-foot containers by $500 – $600 in
2009-10 contracts. However, the group admits these efforts failed to curtail rate volatility, forcing
its carrier members to take more drastic actions. “Recent developments in the Asia-U.S. freight marker
are truly disappointing,” said TSA Executive Administrator Brian Conrad. “The unnecessary panic
mentality that set in during the winter months will cost this industry heavily, if the rates we have been seeing
continue to slide and are locked in over a period of months in new contracts.” The group also noted that
independent UK-based industry analyst Drewery Shipping Contacts forecasts that the global liner shipping sector will
lose $68 billion in the coming year if current rate trends are not reversed.
SIGNALS is provided as a service to its customers
by Distribution-Publications, Inc. © 2006. All rights reserved.
All Issues of SIGNALS are available on the web at
180 Grand Avenue, Suite 430
Oakland, CA 94612-3750
Tel: 1-510-273-8933, or 1-800-204-3622, Fax: 1-510-273-8959,
E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org Web: www.dpiusa.com
“Navigating the Regulatory Seas” is a service mark of Distribution-Publications, Inc.
Vol. 13 No. 5, May 1, 2009
It is subject to change at any time, however, depending on changes in
laws and regulations. While we continually attempt to monitor this
information, we do not guarantee its accuracy and are not responsible
for any damages suffered by any party in reliance on it.